Ty Allen
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
- National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society
Anthony Altala
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
Ethan Ardolino
- NEWMAC Second Team All-Conference
Nathan Basinger
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
- CoSIDA Academic All-District
- CoSIDA First Team Academic All-American
- National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society
Jonathan Berger
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
Reginald Best
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
- National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society
Grant Bordelon
- NEWMAC Second Team All-Conference
Eli Brooks
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
- National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society
Paul Calvetti
- NEWMAC Defensive Athlete of the Week (Sept. 7)
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
- NEWMAC Defensive Athlete of the Year
- NEWMAC First Team All-Conference
- CoSIDA Academic All-District
- New England Football Writers Association All-New England Team
- D3football.com First Team All-Region
- CoSIDA First Team Academic All-American
- Nominated for the Cliff Harris Award as the top small college defensive player in the nation
Michael Cantow
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
Christopher Carratu
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
Marco Cessaratto
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
Greyson D'Aloisio
- National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society
Oakley Dehning
- New England Football Writers Association Gold Helmet (Oct. 25)
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
Antonio Diaz
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
- National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society
Ben Dwyer
- D3Football.com Team of the Week (Oct. 18)
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
- NEWMAC First Team All-Conference
- CoSIDA Academic All-District
- CoSIDA First Team Academic All-American
- National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society
Will Exson
- NEWMAC First Team All-Conference
- D3football.com First Team All-Region
- National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society
Noah Fisher
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
Alonso Garcia
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
Dennis Gastel
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
- NEWMAC Second Team All-Conference
Chris Gaston
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
Ian Gatlin
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
Sam Gozelski
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
- NEWMAC First Team All-Conference
- D3football.com Third Team All-Region
Peyton Greve
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
- National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society
Evan Gwozdz
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
- National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society
Bryce Hancock
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
Preston Hess
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
Michael Holcomb
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
Spencer Hylen
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
- NEWMAC All-Sportsmanship Team
- National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society
Drew Jenkins
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
Cole Kingston
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
- National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society
Brady Klein
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
Stan Lacksen
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
Joe Licht
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
Stephen Lostetter
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
- National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society
John Malloy
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
Chris Mauck
- National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society
Mateo Monterde
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
Jack Montinaro
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
- National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society
Ryan Nall
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
- NEWMAC First Team All-Conference
- CoSIDA Academic All-District
- D3football.com Second Team All-Region
- CoSIDA Second Team Academic All-American
- National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society
Cole Paulin
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
John Readlinger
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
Ashton Robinson
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
- National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society
Keithen Shepard
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
- National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society
George Stultz
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
- National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society
Brady Sullivan
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
Jay Theriault
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
Aidan Van Duzer
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
Steven Van Pelt
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
Loic Venon
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
Christian Viteri
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
William Woltmann
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
- National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society
Ben Wolz
- NEWMAC Academic All-Conference
- National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society
Mark Wright
- NEWMAC Special Teams Athlete of the Week (Sept. 27)
- NEWMAC Special Teams Athlete of the Week (Nov. 15)
- National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society
Adam Zimmermann
- NEWMAC Second Team All-Conference